Skip to content
Official DOJ Response

Darryl Madison’s Official Response to the DOJ Lawsuit Against Madison Tax Services

A statement on IRS examination records, due process, government accountability, professional reputation, and the right to a fair hearing.

Published October 26, 2026

By Darryl J. Madison
Madison Tax Services | Tampa, Florida

My Public Response

My name is Darryl J. Madison. I am a 70-year-old African-American tax professional with approximately 50 years of experience serving individuals, families, and business owners.

On January 15, 2025, the United States Department of Justice published an announcement concerning a civil injunction lawsuit against me, members of my family, and Madison Tax Services.

The government’s announcement accused us of improper tax preparation practices.

I dispute the government’s characterization of my professional conduct, and I believe the American public deserves access to my response and the historical documents underlying this dispute.

My objective is not to avoid legitimate tax obligations. My objective is to obtain the records explaining substantial IRS civil-penalty assessments, establish an accurate accounting of the money collected, and receive a meaningful opportunity to challenge the government’s allegations.

The Original $260,000 Civil-Penalty Dispute

The IRS assessed approximately $260,000 in civil tax-return-preparer penalties associated with 2015, 2016, and 2017.

I maintain that I never received the complete underlying examination reports explaining how those penalties were calculated.

When IRS Collection contacted me around September 2020, I immediately questioned the amount and asked for the original examination documentation.

I have continued requesting these records for approximately six years.

My fundamental question remains: Who prepared the original penalty examination reports, which returns and findings supported the assessments, how were the amounts calculated, and why have the complete records not been furnished to me?

The Documentary Record: Omni Tax Solutions

On August 22, 2022, my authorized representatives at Omni Tax Solutions submitted written correspondence to IRS Revenue Officer Cynthia Spry.

That correspondence documented that records obtained through the Freedom of Information Act concerned separate examinations of my personal 2015 and 2016 income-tax returns, while the production lacked the records explaining the approximately $260,000 in civil preparer penalties.

The correspondence also raised concerns regarding notices sent to a former residential address and difficulty obtaining IRS records during COVID-19 restrictions.

On September 12, 2022, Omni submitted a request for assistance to the Taxpayer Advocate Service concerning the unresolved examination-record dispute.

These documented requests occurred more than two years before the DOJ filed its injunction lawsuit.

E*TRADE Brokerage Collection and Economic Harm

In January 2021, my E*TRADE brokerage investments were affected by IRS collection activity.

I report that the account was restricted and investment options were subsequently liquidated before their scheduled April 2021 expiration.

I estimate that approximately $193,000 to $195,000 was collected or applied toward several IRS liabilities.

I was subsequently informed that a substantial portion had been applied to my 2015 civil preparer penalties, an additional portion to 2016 penalties, and another portion to separate personal income-tax liabilities.

I am requesting a complete accounting establishing the actual amounts, dates, and allocations.

I believe these actions caused severe financial consequences for me and my family, including the loss of investment flexibility, damage to credit relationships, business disruption, and diminished resources for defending subsequent litigation.

These claimed losses require examination of the brokerage records, IRS account transcripts, and related financial evidence.

My Unresolved Offer in Compromise

In August 2024, I submitted Form 656-L, Offer in Compromise based on Doubt as to Liability.

I report that the IRS acknowledged the submission as under review in September 2024.

I maintain that I have not received a final written determination.

Approximately five months later, the DOJ filed its civil injunction lawsuit.

I request disclosure of the administrative processing history of that offer, including the date of receipt, offices responsible for review, actions taken, and any relationship between its consideration and the subsequent DOJ proceedings.

My Concerns About the DOJ Lawsuit

On January 15, 2025, the DOJ initiated a civil injunction lawsuit against me, family members, and Madison & Sons Enterprises, doing business as Madison Tax Services.

The government alleges improper tax-return preparation, including false deductions, business losses, and credits.

I dispute the government’s characterization of our work and seek examination of the specific client returns, billing practices, interview records, and underlying evidence.

The federal court has entered adverse procedural rulings, including striking the defendants’ jury demands and entering a discovery-sanction default. I dispute the fairness of those rulings and seek appropriate review.

I believe the cumulative consequences of IRS collection actions and the DOJ lawsuit have severely impaired my ability to maintain the business, finance my defense, and prepare for retirement.

Although the proceedings involve different legal remedies, I believe their shared factual history and cumulative economic consequences deserve examination.

Judicial Impartiality and the Right to Be Heard

The judge assigned to my case, Kathryn Kimball Mizelle, was nominated to the federal bench by President Donald Trump in 2020 and previously served as a trial attorney in the Department of Justice Tax Division.

These facts, combined with the court’s rulings and the broader political climate, have raised concerns for me about institutional impartiality and confidence in the proceedings.

I have requested an opportunity to present my case to a jury and intend to pursue appropriate avenues for review of the prior jury ruling.

My concern is that ordinary Americans should understand the human and financial consequences of federal enforcement actions, not simply the government’s legal allegations.

Racial Disparities and Minority-Owned Businesses

My tax practice has served working families, entrepreneurs, and small-business owners, including many taxpayers from communities that have historically faced barriers to financial opportunity.

I believe my experience deserves examination against the broader history of racial disparities in taxation, business financing, enforcement, and legal representation.

I am requesting that any allegations of selective enforcement or retaliation be examined through relevant agency records, comparative enforcement data, and the actual circumstances of the decisions concerning my business.

I believe equal treatment under the law requires accountability from the government as well as from taxpayers.

Continuing Examination Requests

In October 2026, I received an additional IRS information document request concerning tax year 2023.

It was dated October 20 and specified an October 30 response deadline. I received it on October 23.

I question the scope and timing of this new request while my longstanding requests for the earlier civil preparer-penalty examination records remain unresolved.

I am seeking the identification of the examination’s purpose, assignment history, responsible officials, and whether it is connected to my other IRS and DOJ proceedings.

My Professional History

Madison Tax Services represents decades of professional service to the Tampa Bay community.

My business history includes professional recognition from Intuit, including a Top 500 Tax Professionals recognition in 2015 and recognition as a Top 50 Firm for tax year 2019.

Local television reporters have also previously sought my professional tax commentary.

Those achievements do not determine the outcome of a legal proceeding, but they are part of the professional history that I believe should be understood before the public forms conclusions about my business.

Historical Timeline

Back To Top